Council to Meet in Private to Discuss Employee Contracts
Contracts for municipal employees, paramedics and the Ocean City Beach Patrol will be discussed in executive session on Aug. 16.
City Council on Monday gave notice of a special executive session — closed to the public — at 6 p.m. Thursday, Aug. 16.
The meeting was scheduled to discuss collective bargaining agreements with:
- Communications Workers of America AFL-CIO, Local No. 1078
- Communications Workers of America AFL-CIO, Local No. 1032
- The International Association of EMTs and Paramedics (IAEP), Local R3/347
- The Ocean City Beach Patrol Administrative Association and the Ocean City Lifeguards Association
The four unions represent the remaining municipal employees working without a renewed contract. All contracts expired at the end of 2011 (with the exception of the Ocean City Beach Patrol, which has not renewed its contract in three years).
The city has come to an agreement with the policemen's union, firefighters' union and Ocean City Pops musicians union.
Salary and wage increases average 1.2 percent over three years for policemen and firefighters.
Eric Sauder
3:20 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Time to get tough with the unions. If they don't want to deal with economic reality the rest of us certainly have to. Wisconsin should be first and foremost on their minds. It really doesn't matter what they think they're entitled to if the taxpayers can't afford it.
JM
6:29 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
I think they've gotten tough. Both police and fire depts took 0% increases for 2012. And let's face 'economic reality' in ocean city -- we actually can afford it. Your taxes are very low.
Mr. B
3:37 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Eric, maybe I missed the part of the article where is says the Union members think they are entitled to something??
Middleclassscapegoatersmissingthetarget
4:14 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Right - Typical thoughtless union-bashing. Keep everyone's dissappointments with their financial lot in life focused on the wrong culprits; or you can better direct your thoughts and energy correctly - at yourself and the extremely wealthy (and their political servants).
Eric Sauder
6:59 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Anyone who's not a member of a union care to comment?
Eric Sauder
7:06 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Let's be honest with each other shall we? If not for the unions union members wouldn't be getting the compensation they're getting (salaries, pensions and benefits). I'm not against unions per say. What I'm saying is that there are many of us can no longer afford the bill. There are gross inequities when you consider that most of use don't reach that level of compensation, have to pay for our benefits, and don't receive a pension. Yet we have to pay for those who do?
Mr. B
7:59 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Eric, I've read this article twice now and still can not find the part you reference as to Union Members feeling entitled to something.
Gabriella Fields
8:46 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Wow!!! It seems that some are reading too much into this article. I too do not see the part where Union Member feel entitled. Maybe Eric can come live in EHT and pay our taxes. My house is assessed at 74,900 and I pay $3500.00 in taxes. Ocean City has THE lowest tax ratable in Cape May and Atlantic Counties. Trade homes with you Eric!!
Eric Sauder
9:45 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
To everyone that's hung up on my use of the word "entitled", it does not appear in the article. A 1.2% average increase over the next 3 years is reasonable. If I were making what union members make I'd be alright with that. I hope a similar agreement can be hammered out Thursday night. But the point is we don't all work for the union. We don't all work for the municipality either. We don't get pensions and most of us have to pay a considerable portion of our health insurance costs, and not only that, we have to pay for YOURS too.
Do you know that there are people living in Ocean City that work for around $8.00 an hour? How the heck are they supposed to survive? It is some of those people who have to pay for those salaries, benefits, and pensions. Where do you think that money comes from? The simple truth of the matter is I'm working fulltime just to pay my taxes. I'm working for YOU. Maybe as someone else pointed out it $*&* to be me.
You pay too much in taxes. I pay $8,000 here but my assessment is much higher. I pay close to $3,000 a year for water and sewer and my last electric bill was over $300. Add to that all the misc fees (tourism, rental, smoke detector) house insurance, heating oil, and I just about break even (I rent a floor of my house in the summer). If you'd like to make a bad investment and can afford the mortgage, we can talk :)
Gabriella Fields
9:12 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Oh, one other thing. Union members so pay just like everybody else. They pay taxes just like every other hard working american. Their compensation is not FREE!!! They contribute and they work hard and care about the jobs they do. It gets very frustrating that all the taxpayers thinks that the union members do NOT pay and they get it all for free. We pay real estate taxes, federal taxes, state and city taxes. Hmmm, looks they they pay taxes just like everybody else and they contribute more that everybody thinks towards pensions. They pay twice, out of payroll and with the state and city taxes. Food for thought!! Stop all the blame games.
VeryConcerned
9:41 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Maybe Eric would like to tell everyone he lives in a Million dollar home (assessed) home a block off the beach!! and has a tax bill of around $7500,, hmmm cheap!!
Eric Sauder
9:48 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Oh gee. Sounds like a good reason to rake everyone over the coals.
VeryConcerned
9:57 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
No, but the amount of complaining or as you say logic, is unbelievable. If it is so bad, sell your house and move, where you can enjoy the perils of your wisdom. I own, I have cheap taxes, I have a public works, police, fire, boardwalk and a beach, for a fraction of the cost of many of the towns in south jersey. and don't you rent out part of your home?? hmmmm
Eric Sauder
10:06 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Excuse me but we pay approximately 40% more in compensation for those services you mention than many of the municipalities around us. WHY?
Eric Sauder
10:07 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
This is a great deal to you?
Gabriella Fields
10:08 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
I'm sorry Eric, I believe I am working for everybody, not just you and not just me. Working is something I enjoy and owning my home and paying a mortgage is something I have earned by hard work and dedication to my job and the people I work for. I too have the water, sewer, electric, gas and other utility bill to pay. I don't blame the public workers for the hard work they do and they deserve to make a living. I am sorry there are so many people for for $8.00 an hour. I know that it is hard to find a good paying job but sometimes you have to start and the bottom. I know I started only making minimum wage and I worked 2 jobs to raise by son by myself. I didn't ask anybody for a pity party, I worked hard and I still do. There are also plenty of people getting ss disability and welfare that we ALL pay for. It's how this great nation works.
Eric Sauder
10:18 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
OK Ann. I'm not asking for a pity party. I'm simply pointing out that there are people living on this island that make a lot less than our public servants make, and they work just as hard. Unfortunately they are also saddled with paying the salaries (pensions and benefits) of public servants that make so much more. That seems inequitable to me. And I'm not just speaking for myself. I work with some of them.
Gabriella Fields
10:23 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
I didn't mean to imply you were looking for a pity party, sorry if you misunderstood me. I too work with some people who make minimum wage, it's a shame. But, didn't we all have to start somewhere and work our way up. We all don't start out making a decent wage.
Eric Sauder
8:38 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Actually I sort of retired here and I'm no longer working in my field. Here you take what you can get. There aren't that many options. I could (and should) be working at a higher level but that would mean working for the municipality or the school system. I'm not a native with connections and I'm not certified in education. Ability doesn't count for much. It's all about who you know and how you play the game.
Since someone pointed it out, my house may be worth close to a million but I doubt it. My neighbors's house just sold for $700,000 something. But that has little meaning in the greater scheme of things. My house isn't worth squat unless I sell it.
As for jobs that start at minimum wage it's rare that there is an up. People who do those jobs are just a commodity. As long as they're willing to do the job they're hired to do, at the wage it pays, they can keep the job or look for another that pays about the same. I suppose I'm underacheiving but that is a part of the consequences of living here, and a choice I made.
VeryConcerned
10:25 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Eric, again, you are misinformed or not understanding of the goverment employee. I have worked in the private and public sector. I "earned a fair wage", not great but fair. You live in a town that is a Billion dollar a year business and affords you the ability to have LOW taxes and a property that most dream of. I am thankful, I have payed the high taxes and am thankful for the way our goverment has kept thing in check. You dont have to go far to see what others are paying, your million dollar home would be paying close to 30,000, let me say that again 30,000 dollars, in TAXES!!!! Think about it. How much do you get in rent, I bet it pays your taxes. I dont have a renter.
Eric Sauder
10:54 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
You know I am fortunate to live here. And our taxes are relatively low due (I think) to a whopping tax base. I've been around the block before with this discussion. The point is, when you spend 40% more for services similar to what other communities receive for 40% less, taxes can (and should be) lowered. It rubs me the wrong way, the inequity of it. I don't know if you read my other posts but there are people living on this island for which it is a hardship to pay their taxes. I guess they should all take your advice and just leave? Rest assured they will leave if they can't afford to live here. That has happened with senior citizens in the past.
Somewhere lost in this discussion is the justification for payng out in compensation what we pay. Is it justified our taxes are relatively low? Do you think it is fair that someone making $16,000 a year (before benefit costs if they can afford it) should be paying the salaries and benefit costs of so many people working for the municipality or working in a union that make $70,000 a year and up? We should be paying competitive wages and benefits. I have to leave for work. Later
VeryConcerned
10:30 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Oh and I forgot to add, I did some research recently and ocean city public employees are not 40% over other municipalities. They are fair and within market value. In most case below market.
Eric Sauder
10:56 pm on Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Well I know of some that are. I can't get into it now. Gotta go.
Dubert
6:45 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Eric's initial comment of time to get tough on the Unions is accurate. Unions only serve to keep bad to worthless employees employeed and the pay rate of ggod employees lower than it should be. They have lost their way, and as far as entitlement goes, you can see the sense of entitlement in JM's comment that police and fire took a 0%increase in 2012. Took? Why should they recieve anything? Raises should be awarded on skill, ability, performance and attitude, not based on the passage of another year. Disgusting
JM
5:12 pm on Thursday, August 16, 2012
Are you saying Ocean City employees are not skilled or able? Bad attitudes? Don't perform at a high level? That's a joke. These are the people that run this town and make it one of the most successful resorts in the nation. This isn't corrupt Trenton or the DRPA.
Mr. B
7:19 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
40% more than other municipalities? where are these statistics? please, amuse me.
Dubert, raises given based on skill, ability and performance? and who would be the person to decide these factors and hand out the raises? see how well that goes over, every hear of favoritism? cronyism?
Eric Sauder
9:19 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Well Mr. B, what is the median salary of a teacher in Upper Township? Is it $90,000?
What is the average salary for a fireman? Is it $100,000? Someone researched it and posted to Patch that the national average is somewhere around $60,000. I suspect you'd find the same disparity with the police department. The 40% figure came from a council member during the debates. I can attest that he's a numbers guy and doesn't pull numbers out of a hat. And interestingly enough it seems to hold true (do the math). If you're going to run numbers at me (say for public works) please be sure the averages don't reflect seasonal employees that everyone knows don't make squat.
Have I heard of favoritism and cronyism? Are you kidding me? Don't forget I live here too.
John Smith
8:31 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Eric-do you forget Gov. Whitman raiding the pension funds then telling towns that they do not have to make their contributions? OC has the cheapest taxes for the most services then surrounding towns (EHT, SP, SIC and Avalon have almost entirely all volunteer Fire/Rescue Dept) what about when all the realtors and contractors who were making all that money buying houses and turning them into duplexes. public service is great in OC and our public workers are compensated fairly for it... you get what you pay for... if you have a million dollar home you are going to pay that in taxes... you think that is too much down size to a condo or better yet move... maybe we can hire those fire companies in Colorado that are private and only put fires out in homes that paid for their service, i'm sure Blackwater would bid on a security contract and then we can get a contractor to cover public works... remember you get what you pay for!
Eric Sauder
9:27 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
John your comment demands more of a response than I have time to give it now. I don't see how you get what you pay for if you pay more for it than its worth. From everything I've heard I think we should consider outsourcing. Anyway I'll get back to you later. It reminds me of the comment that Reagan made too many years ago (and I paraphrase). "The next time you complain about how much government costs, just be glad you don't get all the government you pay for."
Mr. B
10:44 am on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Eric, how do you come to the conclusion that you pay more than it's worth? I think you need to stop portraying your opniona as fact. or, show me the numbers and facts. I hope you can find it in your time to respond with this information. thank you.
Eric Sauder
4:14 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I just did. We pay 40% more for services that are more or less the same as what other communities enjoy. That's paying more for a service than it's worth (in my opinion). Perhaps you're challenging the 40%? I trust the source of that comment and I illustrated where that holds true. Your point is well taken that I did not provide median income for teachers in Upper Township. I don't know what it is which is why I asked you. I know teachers in Upper that obviously know what they make and know what their counterparts make in Ocean City. According to them it is considerably more in Ocean City. Is it 40% more? I don't know what the exact percentage is and I didn't ask them what they make. I'm satisfied that it is "considerably more."
Maybe you dispute the numbers.I did use. I feel I can rely on what other people have stated, about the national average salary for a firefighter for example. But if it makes you feel better I can look it up for myself and get back to you.
Now that we've been all over the place with this I'd like t restate what I stated earlier. It is because of the unions that union members make what they make (in total compensation) and I believe that compensation is inflated because of collective bargaining. If you don't agree with that statement fine but I'm not going to argue it with you. And there's a gross inequity when you consider that it's a hardship for some of the people who live here to pay those salaries who make so much less.
Sam Lavner
12:36 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I'm a non-union person, self-employed, doing pretty well, and live and pay property taxes here. From my point of view, the unions have done an excellent job in negotiating contracts over the years. If you don't like the outcomes, then you should more properly direct your grievances at the party representing you in the contract negotiations: the administration (and then council who must approve the deals). Unions and the city are supposed to enter the negotiation seeking the best deal for their constituencies. I bet the unions do. Not sure the city does; and if not that is likely attributable to politicians seeking (electoral) reward from union members and their family and friends. Regardless of the motives, congrats to the unions. I am happy that they earn a solid middle class income, that they and their families have good health insurance, and am just as happy to contribute to both. I reserve my frustration for the dynamics that weaken and shrink the middle class, not strengthen it.
Eric Sauder
5:42 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Ok I did some research. Here's some numbers from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. I could only compare OC with Vineland / Millville / Bridgeton. They don't list statistics for every township / munciplaity. Unfortunately they don't list all catergories for every municipality / township either. These are all means.
OCNJ
Mid & high school teachers $65,000
School administration $116,000
Police department (admin) $103,500
Police department patrol $ 73,500
Vineland / Millville / Bridgeton
Mid and high school teacher $63,000 to $65,000
School administration $99,900
Police (patrol) $72,000
Firefighter $61,000
I can't interpret these numbers. They are what they are. The median income for teachers wasn't available so I don't know how MVB stacks up to $90,000. It would have been nice to see the mean salary for firefighters in OC but that wasn't available either. It has been widely reported as around $100,000.
Eric Sauder
5:51 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
If seasonal patrolmen salaries are factored into the average those averages are undoubtedly skewed.
Mr. B
6:00 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Eric, you have still NOT provided the facts behind your statement that Ocean City pays 40% more than other communities, I truly hope you are not just saying that because thats what someone else said once. if so, are you aware that I invented the internet, and you can believe everything you read on it? Please, provide your facts behind YOUR statements. stop dancing around the issue.
Eric Sauder
6:58 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Obviously Mr. B I can't satisfy you. I spent a couple of hours looking up the numbers for you from the Bureau of Labor and Statistics but apparently that doesn't mean anything to you either. I think maybe you need to do it for yourself. I don't have the time to get into a butter / parkay argument with you (sorry).
VeryConcerned
6:14 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Sam, its not worth it, he's been on this soap box for years and continues to compare Ocean City to the middle of no where. We are a unique town and really dont compare to the national medium and he doesnt get it. He just wants to enjoy his ocean view and complain about it. Or, he could sell his million dollar (assessed) home, probably get 1.5 mill cash, move to Tennessee, on a lake, in a mansion, lots of acres, and prepay his taxes for the next 10 years, with cash in the bank. NOPE, keep's complaining about how HIGH his (low)taxes really are and the way its handled. You know, Clean streets, clean beach, paid police and fire and some of the best weather you could ask for. Not that we pay taxes for weather.
Eric Sauder
8:01 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I fail to see the reson for all the personal attacks. Maybe you should read other people's comments before you respond to them? I had to use MVB because there are no statistics for a commuinity closer to us.
VeryConcerned
6:16 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Yes, Eric, you are so right, "my bad" ,,,Ocean City is just like Vineland, Millville and BRIDGETON!!! Dude, now research how much they pay in taxes!!!
VeryConcerned
6:29 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
How much would your 1.1 mill (assessed) home, pay in taxes in those cumberland county towns!! The cheapest, is Vineland and you would pay 22,000 Dollars. You will never get the same services as you do now. Please Stop, before you continue to make yourself look like a fool. By the way you would pay 35,000 dollars in Bridgeton. *tax rates from the NJ division of taxation
VeryConcerned
6:21 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Eric, I believe your in the service industry?? Right? If you worked at a much slower establishment, Do you deserve less pay for your services. Would you accept a lower amount of pay, for your time? If the same business accross the bridge does twice as much work or not, would you accept a lower wage scale?
Joe Smerconish
6:31 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Well stated Sam - and absolutely correct. I'm non-union too but know enough economics and american history to know that collective bargaining is what built the middle class and that, as much as anything else, is what made America great.
Ocbeacbum
6:37 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
You also forgot that the OC fireman work a 56 hr workweek and most others especially around here work a 42 hr workweek that has also been said before.
Eric Sauder
7:23 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
You know what? I'm out of this argument. No one seems to give a rip about anyone else. I get it already. You're in the union. Its all about YOU. #%#^ everyone else and if they can't afford it they can move. I'd be defensive too if I were in your shoes.
I must have missed the brainwashing session where they convinced everyone that we have such superior services because we pay more for them. I witnessed enough of the manuevering and fear tactics over attempts to bring spending under control in the fire department. It was brave thing for Hartzell and Ping to attempt. They're certainly astute enough politically to know the risk of taking on a union.
Eric Sauder
7:28 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I was sympathetic at one point. My suggestion was that the fire department be given a target and free reign to come up with their own way fo meeting that objective. I understand its like a brotherhood and the first and foremost directive is to protect your turf and each other. Keep it up. As long as this City can come up with the funds to maintain that level of spending you'll suceed. But at some point unless this economy turns around and property values go back up it will come tumbling down. The hard chioces will HAVE to be made as they were in Wisconsin. That is the reality.
I've heard it all before ... how you put your lives on the line, how you work a lot of hours. But you get to go home. You get to see your wife and family. No one is trying to kill you. You can assume today won't be the last day of your life. You do get time off. What are our troops paid for making their sacrifice?.
Eric Sauder
7:39 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I'm ticked now for taking all the heat I had to take for challenging the unions. I knew it was coming. You did make a concession in that the pay increase over the next 3 years is modest. The problem is we're paying too many people too much and have been for too long. It's not just the extra $40,000 in salaries per fire fighter (compared to the average) but the cost of the pensions based on that income.
Eric Sauder
7:43 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I apprediate what you guys do. I really do. I wish it began and ended there.
Sam Lavner
8:41 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
Eric - Assuming the people posting in favor of good compensation and also in support of unions are all union members and responding to their points based on that assumption is wrong in two important ways: 1. Not all of them are in unions and 2. The merits of the points should be what counts, not the motive behind them. And while I'm at it; you say in an earlier post that it is inequitable (I interpret that to mean that you think it is unfair) that some taxpayers are paying toward public worker compensation packages that are greater than the taxpayers make. Assuming that this is actually unfair (I do not think it is at all), how would you remedy that scenario? You don't have to think too hard about it to see that it is, in reality, impossible to make that equitable using your standard...And, finally, you cannot establish a solid rational basis for your complaint about our public workers' compensation unless you can identify legitimately comparable jobs (duties, geography, population served, etc) and you can establish that those comparables have a sound fiscal basis. Good luck with that. So, we are left with the rates being determined by what the market will bare. Our negotiation outcomes have born that out as is proven by them being consitent over the years.
Eric Sauder
8:54 am on Thursday, August 16, 2012
Sam I tried to post twice to your comment and both times my comments disappeared. You're right that you can't know who you're conversing with on Patch so my apologies. I tried to stay on message but I felt the need to respond to some of those comments (and the lack of response to elements of mine) and got sidetracked at times.
If it is true, as widely reported, that our firefighters make on the average around $100,000 a year, then we're overpaying for that service (based on the AVERAGE for other communities.) I take issue with the statement that "you get what you pay for." I think a fireman working for $60,000 a year will do as good of a job at fire suppression as a firefighter who makes $100,000 a year.
As for what to do about it, that's always the hard part. Murphy (the union representative) stated that new firefighters coming in are on a different pay scale, and will never make what the older firefighters make. I haven't seen the agreement, but if true that will help close the gap over time. I never negotiatied with a union and I don't know if you could do it, but I would establish compensation caps. If you maxed out on your cap you should be exempt from further raises. Over the next couple of decades that might close the disparity.
As for what we got into some time ago I'm beginning to believe you ,may have been right, at least from a practical point of view.
Mr. B
9:46 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
average median firefighter salary for Ocean City firefighter is 46,052.00 national average median is 41,969.00
Eric Sauder
9:03 am on Thursday, August 16, 2012
I'm curious to know where you got that number (for Ocean City).
The Great Cockarooski
10:35 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
HE WHO MAKES A BEAST OF HIMSELF, GETS RID OF THE PAIN OF BEING A MAN.....Eric, I think you need to buy some goldfish son
outoftownerwhocares
11:11 pm on Wednesday, August 15, 2012
In one year, a firefighter on the 56-hour work week schedule works 728 hours above the number worked by a 40-hour employee. If applied to a twenty-five-year career, the 56-hour employee will have worked an additional 8.75 years, or the equivalent of 33.75 40-hour/week years.
archie struthers
2:52 pm on Saturday, August 25, 2012
No interest in getting in the middle of this except for the continued mistakes regarding taxes in OCNJ .... they are in fact quite high as are all the taxes in NJ. everyone generally forgets our assessments are incredibly high , so the rate becomes secondary . LOTS of our beachfront owners paying 25-30K per year, with no children to educate for the vast majority.
For what we pay the streets are awful and the town infrastructure is a mess. Yet , the beauty of a beach town makes it hard to beat.