Bloody End to Water Balloon Attack Steams Night in Venice Captain
Duke O' Fluke owner Brook Koeneke considers a lawsuit after the July 28 incident.
Night in Venice, Ocean City's annual boat parade and bayside celebration, soured this year for Capt. Brook Koeneke when a water balloon launched from a massive slingshot bloodied a 78-year-old passenger on his fishing boat.
A group of Ocean City neighbors from Delancey Place had chartered Koeneke's Duke O' Fluke pontoon boat, decorated it with a "Lazy, Hazy, Crazy Days of Summer" theme to participate in the parade, and were leaving the Venetian Bayou Lagoon between Bayshore Drive and West 17th Street along the parade route, when the projectiles began to fly from within a row of multimillion-dollar waterfront homes hosting lavish parties.
Two water balloons missed, and the third struck John Patrick, a resident of the 200 block of Ocean Avenue in Ocean City, in the face. Patrick suffered a bloody nose and a swollen lip, according to Koeneke — minor injuries for which he would later refuse treatment from Ocean City Fire Department EMTs.
But the incident left Koeneke fuming, and he said this week that he's continuing to explore the possibility of a lawsuit against the owners of the property where he claims the water balloons were launched.
For Koeneke, the incident illustrates the dangerous side of the famously "wet" celebration in the dry town of Ocean City. Night in Venice includes hundreds of legal private parties along the bayfront during and after the boat parade — but the communal drunkenness often spills into public view and has long stood in contrast with the resort's carefully protected image as a family resort.
"If this kind of behavior is allowed to continue, there's going to be a tragedy," Koeneke said.
The incident is also a story of contemptuousness to Koeneke — when he left the parade and approached the property with his boat, the partygoers took no responsibility for the alleged incident and had no regard for the injured passenger.
"It's typical of the arrogant upper class," Koeneke said. "These were doctors, lawyers and educated adults standing there watching their adult children doing this kind of crap."
Koeneke said he saw six shirtless males — "all 20-something," as he estimated their ages — including three who were operating the slingshot, two holding the bands and one launching the balloon.
After the water balloon struck Patrick, Koeneke turned the boat around, radioed the Coast Guard to ask for assistance and got on the loudspeaker as he approached the property along Bayshore Drive on the south side of the lagoon.
The Ocean City Police Department and the Fire Department EMTs responded quickly, Koeneke said. But by the time police arrived, the young males had dissappeared into the house and the partygoers offered no assistance to police, according to Koeneke.
"There were a couple lawyers in the crowd," he said. "And the officers immediately encountered resistance."
According to the Ocean City Police Department incident report from July 28, officers arrived at 267 Bayshore Drive at 7:14 p.m. and later found and confiscated a water balloon launcher on the property. Koeneke said it had been thrown in the bushes.
The Duke O' Fluke had docked nearby, where Patrick refused treatment from EMTs and said he "did not wish any police action taken for this incident."
"There were approximately 30 people present for a Night in Venice party," the police report says. "All present at the party denied launching the water balloons."
Because Patrick did not want to press charges, police discontinued the investigation, and no charge was filed against anybody.
The police report lists the owner of the home as Pamela Stebbins, 60.
The property is among the top 100 most valuable in Ocean City, according to 2011 tax records. The records list the owners as Stebbins and Dr. David Arluck.
Stebbins did not return a call asking for her description of the incident.
Koeneke said Patrick had just had cataract surgery and was not wearing eyeglasses at the time he was struck by the water balloon. If he had been, Koeneke said, the injury could have been much worse.
"This wasn't just a slingshot," he said. "It was a weapon."
He said he grew up in an era when parents would hold their children accountable for their actions.
"If I had done something like that, I know what would have happened to me," Koeneke said. "And I would have stepped up and apologized. If that had happened, I wouldn't still be talking about this."
"I'm hoping the threat of a lawsuit will bring these punks forward."
Tom Murphy, the Somers Point lawyer representing Koeneke, said that any potential lawsuit would not include a victim who suffered damages — a common foundation of civil suits. But he said he is exploring other options.
"How much money should somebody have to spend to prove a point?" Murphy said. "And should he have to."
Mark Soifer, the long-time Ocean City public relations director who helps organize the event, said the boat parade has experienced similar incidents "off and on" throughout the years.
He said he plans to mail a letter to all bayfront property owners in January warning them of the dangers and consequences of such behavior.
"It's no joke," Soifer said.
Richard Jacoby
7:58 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Hold the property owner responsible for the actions of his guests. Just another one of these rich pricks thinking they can do anything they want and as always nothing was really done. The cops are always so quick to say they don't need a victims consent to bring charges, but throw a scumbag lawyer into the mix and they run like cowards.
Virgil Harris
1:39 am on Thursday, September 6, 2012
I am not condoning their behavior, but don't be that poor guy who hates! Any rich guys can do whatever they want because they can afford the consequences.
Tim Zatzariny Jr.
8:52 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Richard, I understand, and share, your frustration over this incident. But, we shouldn't blame the Ocean City police here. It sounds like they were vigilant in investigating the incident. You're right that police don't need a victim's consent to file charges, but they do need a cooperative witness, or some other solid evidence, otherwise any charges would be quickly dismissed in court. In this case, the slingshot itself as evidence is not enough, because there seemed to be no proof of who fired it.
Richard Jacoby
4:03 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Because Patrick did not want to press charges, police discontinued the investigation, and no charge was filed against anybody.
That's right out of the article. Sounds like the boat owner was willing to be a cooperative witness. I don't blame OCPD for the incident but they certainly could have done something. To me this ranks a little higher on the importance meter then the PA driver going 33 in a 30 mph zone and there is certainly no breaks cut there.
Duffer
10:34 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Everyone needs a good lawsuit.
Richard Jacoby
3:51 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
If its the rich doctor and not the taxpayer getting sued, then by all means sue his @ss. You would think an educated person of his age could hold a party without this BS.
flinn
10:36 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Why do the moronic locals continue to hold this event every year when it has obviously degenerated into a drunkfest.
Gloria
11:23 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Dear Flinn,
We do it to induce the visiting morons who can't live without booze, to visit and bring buckets of money!
Chris M
9:51 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
It's not us locals holding the event. I can't stand it.
Mary B
11:21 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
As with all things, people do not know moderation. We enjoy a good party during Night in Venice and it should not be cancelled because of the poor judgement of a few knuckleheads (and it has nothing to do with your income level). The young men and their parents put everyone in danger. No wonder its so difficult to find a charter for the evening! I'm thankful the victim is okay.
Gloria
11:21 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
So, after all these years living in OC I finally learn that the rules AREN'T different for our "Summer Visitors" who own all of the great big empty houses sitting empty 9 months a year? They are bound by the same rules and laws that the, Ughhh (seagull poop) "lOCals are?!!! OMG!!!! Whom ever will tell them?
Chuck Biscuits
11:27 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
The same crap has been happening since I was a kid. I remember a capt. pulling a spear gun out when drunken idiot shoobs threw ice at his boat. The deal is when alcohol and stupidity are mixed it's a shit show. Glad I live offshore.
Louissa
11:29 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
sad truth, Gloria - those empty houses all pay big taxes to this town. Too bad that the Realtors and Developers leveled all the old single homes and put up plastic boxes that do not appeal to the year round resident the realtors, developers, insurance agents - all made big money and still do having those empty houses - turning them over to renters and new owners ---- so it will never change now - too bad the bogus "committee to preserve OC" didn't step in then and do something but since they are a bunch of phony hypocrites themselves, never happen
buhbyeshoobie
11:47 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
I think that it would be nice if the people that used the sling shot apologized to the gentleman that was hit. That's the problem with booze people say and do things that they would never do sober. Its a shame it has to come down to lawsuits, that will result in some crappy law that is obviously common sense Don't throw things at people, We really did learn everything we need to know in kindergarten.
Robert McKenna, MIKE
11:52 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Louissa, I think you hit the proverbial nail on the head. I agree too The Night in Venice has always been a drunken party, but well contained. The Night in Venice is a long-standing tradition of summer fun in Ocean City. However, the incidents described in the article are unacceptable, and if left unpunished then this is the beginning of the end for The Night in Venice party.
Chris M
10:04 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Love when NIV is described as drunken summer fun in a town that appalled at the sight of alcohol.
jane mc c
11:59 am on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Maybe it's about time, we reconsider our national marketing logo, OC the World's Greatest FAMILY Resort. A family that stands by while this is being set-up, watches their young adults fill large balloons with water and then launch them at a vessel filled with passengers is on the same level as a thug living in a crackhouse standing by while an innocent pedestrian gets mugged and then deny seeing, hearing or knowing anything about the mugging. Wow, way to go! and this let's your guests learn something about themselves, too. Honor, Truth or a good party.
OC4EVER
12:44 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Dr. Arluck should be held accountable. He is the property owner. I don't know what his specialty is as a doctor, but I know if he can't be a stand up guy for what happens at his house then I would never think about using him as a doctor. He's a real scumbag.
Chris M
9:55 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Amen
jimmy wildwood
1:22 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
On advice of counsel, the youths advised they were defending themselves against vessels ignoring the no wake zone, creating a substantial hazard to the innocent souls trapped on the deck w/ cocktails. Hello, Coasties?? Also, that boat had a large round (bullseye?) on it. An attractive nuisance. Jimmy finds for the defense. First round is on me.
Richard Jacoby
3:55 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Imagine if a boat went by and shot crap at this doctors house and injured one of his family members or damaged his house. I bet he wouldn't be too happy. And I bet the boater would not have got away with it.
Duffer
6:38 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
You might think somebody was murdered. Better call the waaaaambulance and a boatload of lawyers.
Richard Jacoby
9:49 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
The best barometer to determine that you are on the right side of an issue is when this guy disagrees with you.
Chris M
9:54 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Richard, don't waste your time. This guys an Internet troll operating under a fake name I've seen his post over the last year, it ridiculous. Six months ago, you would have thought someone was getting murdered over a bottle of wine, if you read his posts.
SPW
7:03 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
No standing.......only the injured has standing here. Unfortunate, but another frivolous law suit....unless the Capt refunded the $$$ and he is looking for compensation...then he isn't the "social activist" he purports
There's always another agenda
Doug Watkins
7:16 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
We've had our boat "attacked" in this same area multiple years. You can't cure stupid......and the "kids" were stupid; same stupidity was water hoses and throwing candy. The injured party deserves the recompense
No more marine unit and less NJSP/USCG are available to monitor
Given history of 17th-18th St, maybe they'll need to patrol better
Unfortunate, but law suit (particularly since Capt wasn't injured party) is another example of the courts being over burdened with garbage
Chris M
9:59 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Njsp/uscg are too busy harassing responsible boaters to be bothered with anything or importance.
Richard Jacoby
9:43 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
Yes, what should have happened is the property owner held responsible. I am sure the police could come up with some charge if he wouldn't point out the individuals responsible. Disorderly conduct, possession. Of an instrument of crime withholding information from authorities or some sort of BS. Unless you truely believe the doctor or homeowner had a water balloon cannon operating in his back yard and didn't know who was using it.
as for those who think its no big deal, why don't you ride your bike down the steet and allow me to fire one of those things at your head. And we will see how you like it.
Al Czervik
2:35 pm on Monday, September 3, 2012
How bout if you do us all a favor and let us shoot it at you
Chris M
5:34 pm on Monday, September 3, 2012
Al, I happen to be a neighbor of Richard, and if you did shoot it at him, it would probably be the last thing you ever did. I know I wouldn't
Janine Hargrove
10:31 pm on Sunday, September 2, 2012
I think that particular homeowner IS a local.
Public Servant ret'd
1:37 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
buhbyeshoobie nailed this one! Imagine if the boat docked, and the accused came forward and admitted their actions. A simple "We're sorry, we were just goofing off!' prolly would have put this whole matter to bed!
Richard Jacoby
7:04 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
And you would expect that out of this caliber of people. I guess being a doctor no longer implies trust you have an once of class.
Roy H Zehner
1:53 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
whew...who hasn't been hit with a water balloon? Unfortunately someone got hurt...but lawsuits, all this anger, 'can't we all just be friends'?
Richard Jacoby
6:44 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
It's about Volocity. This wasn't 5 year olds playing with water balloons. these things are shot with quite a bit of force. Trust me when I say, you wouldn't be smiling if you took one in the face.
Richard Jacoby
6:45 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
And these weren't willing participants in a water balloon fight. You people amaze me.
Duffer
6:56 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
Its about lawyers,money and people who can't settle things like men or move on with their life. Pathetic.
Richard Jacoby
6:48 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
I guess it's ok if kids play by throwing projectiles off overpasses. Hey, it's only in the name of fun.
Robert McKenna, MIKE
11:01 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
Spew all the angry rhetoric you want but the bottom line is the victim chose not to press charges. It is not like the crack house example, unless you state the only reason a crack house exists is because the neighbors won't relentlessly bring charges and allow the police and the court to act. As much blame lies with the victim for not pressing charges. I am certainly no lawyer but at what point can OC police act without a filed complaint? What side are the police on in this situation? I know the OC police love to push their weight around... why not in this case?
Chris M
6:02 pm on Monday, September 3, 2012
You certainly are not a lawyer, victims don't make the call to press charges. The police and or DA do. It matters NOT that the victim didnt want to press charges. The police had an eye witness to the entire incident, in the boat operator
Robert McKenna, MIKE
11:10 am on Monday, September 3, 2012
Chris, this town is not appalled by the sight of alcohol, nor is there anyone trying to take away peoples' right to drink. The argument about alcohol in restaurants has nothing to do with people enjoying a social drink in their home. The people voted not to pass drinking in restaurants because it is part of the uniqueness and history of this town. A few drunks with water balloons hardly support a double standard.
Suzanne Hornick
4:44 pm on Monday, September 3, 2012
What ever happened to personal responsibility, honesty, integrity and morals?
Bottom lines are;
Those sling shots (my kids have one) can send water balloons traveling up to 300 feet and 70ish mph according to the package and are extremely dangerous when launching something that weighs a couple of pounds. They are most assuredly potential weapons! I'd like to see any of you nay sayers out there still say its no big deal after getting hit that hard! These were not children doing this, they were Adult (?) men who have lawyers as friends/family who CHOOSE not to take responsibility for thier actions ,being hidden by a local doctor who still expects locals to trust him. I know I never will and he has treated several of my family members. How sad!
My son inadvertently got hit on the thigh by one of our launched balloons while standing on the beach about 150 feet away( we thought that was a safe distance and then some) and the deep bruise lasted almost a month and was the size of a grapefruit. It was launched by little kids so I can't imagine how much force one launched by adults would have!
I applaud the Captain for trying to protect and defend his customers/passengers as well as any future sailors who might have the misfortune of sailing near Dr. Arbucks and Pamela Stebbins house.
Here are some links ;
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QrUxZBi9kCk&feature=youtube_gdata_player
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z22Q1nC4rBo&feature=youtube_gdata_player
Chris M
5:31 pm on Monday, September 3, 2012
Suzanne. Spot on comment. Couldn't agree more
Richard Jacoby
5:52 pm on Monday, September 3, 2012
Suzanne. Excellent post. Refreshing to read a rational point of view. You must live off island.
Robert McKenna, MIKE
6:24 pm on Monday, September 3, 2012
I too applaud Suzanne for an informative post. All the more reason there should be an investigation and arrest. However, according to the article, the OC police discontinued investigation, and no charges were filed. According to Chris M, the police had an eye witness, and victims do not make the call to discontinue investigations because they don't want to press charges. So again I as what is up with the police? Why are the police not pursuing the case anyway?
chris
12:03 am on Tuesday, September 4, 2012
I had a friend who had their 6yr old and 8yr old sons fined for playing in the dunes. In a America's Greatest FAMILY Resort you would think the police would use a liitle fear tactics and send them on their way. This is the double standards about OC that people hate. A bunch of rich adult drunks injuire someone and the police turn the other way but a child at play gets fined.
Robert McKenna, MIKE
8:49 am on Tuesday, September 4, 2012
Absolutely, Chris!! So let's give one of the highest paid police forces in the country another raise for their favoritism and double standards! By the way, before the police lovers attack me for making false statements about pay, I figure the cops only really work three months a year, and make over a hundred grand with an enviable retirement package that rivals the old days of the auto workers. Accepting that premise what police force makes more and does less? If at least they protected and served ALL the people, maybe the outrageous pay could be justified.
Jon Adams
10:07 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012
Find me one Ocean City Police Officer who "really only works three months a year, and makes over a hundred grand with an enviable retirement package" Just because a large majority of the people posting here only see them during the 3 months that they vacation here, doesn't mean OCPD isn't working 12 months a year
Jon Adams
10:09 pm on Wednesday, September 12, 2012
however, we digress, this isn't, and never was, about Ocean City Police payroll
Kathy
12:42 pm on Tuesday, September 4, 2012
Apparently this guy is a big heart doc in Somers Point. He doesn't seem to have any heart or common sense. What is he teaching these adults that were on his property? Grow a set and man up. Show your family that you are a man with manners and morals.